The University of Iowa
The University of Iowa News Services Home News Releases UI in the News Subscribe to UI News Contact Us

University of Iowa News Release

April 19, 2006

UI Law Student Group Buys One Ton of Pollution

A student group at the University of Iowa College of Law is now the proud owner of one ton of sulfur dioxide emissions. They plan to keep the ton, but fortunately don't need to find a closet big enough to store it.

"By purchasing one ton of sulfur dioxide emissions, that's one ton of emissions that will never be produced and never become pollution," said Harmony Mappes, co-president of the law school's Environmental Law Society. "In addition, by bidding up the price, we make it more expensive for companies to produce these pollutants and, we hope, encourage them to install pollution control technologies to reduce their emissions."

The ELS purchased the emissions for $425 during the U.S. EPA's annual emissions auction in March. Under federal law, producers of sulfur emissions must buy shares at auction in order to produce more emissions than what the law allows. 

Sulfur dioxide emissions are typically produced by manufacturing plants that are powered by burning such sulfur-containing fuels as coal. Once in the atmosphere, sulfur dioxide emissions can cause respiratory problems, particularly to children, the elderly and people with asthma, sometimes causing long-term respiratory illness. Sulfur dioxide is also a major factor in acid rain, harming plants, animals, soil and water resources, as well as cause damage to man-made structures, such as buildings and statues. 

Energy plants tend to be the largest producers of emissions, although metal processing facilities, cement manufacturing facilities, petroleum refineries, locomotives and large ships also produce the gas.

The Clean Air Act established a minimum amount of sulfur dioxide emissions that a single manufacturing plant can produce, Mappes said. Beyond that, producers must buy additional shares, or allowances, on the open market that originate with the EPA. The theory, Mappes explained, is that producers will find ways to reduce sulfur dioxide emissions if they have to pay too much to produce more emissions than they're allotted.

Although it may seem odd that a group dedicated to a clean environment may buy the rights to produce a pollutant, Mappes said purchasing the emissions takes advantage of market economics to achieve their goal. To drive up the price of emissions and increase the costs to emissions producers, environmental groups purchase allowances in the EPA auction. Other organizations include student environmental groups at such colleges and universities as Creighton, University of Wisconsin-Parkside, Kenyon College and Clarkson University. Other environmental organizations that purchase allowances are the Clean Air Conservancy, Acid Rain Retirement Fund and Maryland Environmental Law Society.

Mappes said the ELS raised $425 to buy the emissions allowance through fund-raising events during the year, mostly bake sales. The amount they spent for one ton of emissions pales against the purchase made by the largest buyer in this year's auction, Morgan Stanley Capital Group, which spent $10 million to purchase more than 39 million tons.

"These purchases of just a few tons are small compared to some of the facilities that buy thousands of tons at a time, but every little bit helps keep the air cleaner," said Mappes.

STORY SOURCE: University of Iowa News Service, 300 Plaza Centre One, Suite 371, Iowa City, Iowa 52242-2500.

MEDIA CONTACT: Tom Snee, 319-384-0010,