CONTACT: DEREK MAURER
Iowa City IA 52242
(319) 335-8964; fax (319) 335-8034
Release: Oct. 30, 2000
UI study: No 'uncomplicated joy' in good news for individuals tested for
IOWA CITY, Iowa -- Good news from genetic screening tests can bring more
to its recipients than relief: it also can bring doubts about the future and,
in some cases, guilt. A University of Iowa study reported recently that individuals
who received negative results from genetic screening for Huntington disease
-- meaning they did not carry the gene mutation that causes the debilitating
and fatal disorder -- usually "were not prepared for the implications
of a 'good news' test outcome."
"They never reported uncomplicated joy," said Janet Williams,
Ph.D., associate professor of nursing at the UI and principal investigator
for the study. "The joy and relief were accompanied by concerns"
about how family members might receive the news and how to adjust to a life
now free of anxiety about when symptoms of Huntington disease might begin
to appear. Some even doubted the test results, the study reported.
Published in the journal Research in Nursing & Health, the study involved
a small number of individuals over a relatively short period of time. Even
so, Williams said, it identified important themes with respect to genetic
testing. First and foremost, informed consent and one-on-one counseling should
be a part of every testing program.
"Many of the people we talked with were working this out on their own,"
Williams said. "Health providers should be aware that this is a group
that may benefit from supportive counseling."
Huntington disease affects about one in 20,000 people and is caused by a
single gene mutation. Individuals who carry the mutation almost invariably
develop the disease unless they die of some other cause prior to its onset.
Huntington disease is characterized by a progressive loss of cognitive and
physical function and usually begins to manifest itself between the ages of
30 and 50. The course of the disease may last anywhere from 10 to 25 years.
Each child of an individual with Huntington disease has a 50 percent chance
of inheriting the gene mutation. Thus, Williams said, families with a history
of Huntington disease generally have an intimate understanding of the illness
and a sense of shared risk. When a family learns one of its members has sought
genetic testing for the mutation, its group dynamic may be altered irreversibly.
"People who have this test are often departing from family norms,"
Williams said, "and that somewhat isolates these individuals."
Family relationships may be further upset when an individual's negative
test result contradicts the expectation that he or she will develop the disease.
Williams explained that a phenomenon known as preselection often exists within
families with a history of Huntington disease. Consciously or unconsciously,
family members assign risk to individuals based on beliefs about who is likely
to develop the illness; for example, if in previous generations the oldest
child often inherited Huntington disease, family members may assume that will
be true in their case as well.
When that assumption proves false, Williams said, families face the need
to adapt. "Biological information such as this removes the comfort they
may have had in 'knowing' who was going to get the disease," she said.
"There are a number of issues that mean life is not going to be the same
within the family once a person learns they don't have it."
The individual's response to a negative test result is no less complicated.
According to the study, "Adults with normal results had prepared themselves
for the worst, and they expected that they would have the gene mutation."
"I think that's their coping mechanism," said Catherine Evers,
a co-author of the study and an advanced practice nurse who is coordinator
of the Regional Genetic Consultation Service based at UI Hospitals and Clinics.
"When you tell them they don't have it, based on a gene test that's very
accurate, some of them have a hard time believing you," Evers said. "We've
had individuals say to us, 'we'd better do the test again.'"
Study participants had difficulty knowing how to relate to family members
who might have the disease. One individual spoke of encountering a cousin
who has Huntington disease, "who I related to really easily before, because
I figured I was going to be in the same boat, but it was harder for me to
feel the same empathy
. I didn't tell him, I could not tell him my test
results." Another reported that while some relatives were supportive,
"there've been other people that have been almost jealous. Those are
the ones that I regret telling."
Ultimately, the study said, individuals who learn they do not carry the
gene for Huntington disease face the need to redefine their goals and purpose
in life. Six months after learning their test results, participants "began
to discard their prior assumptions and started to consider themselves as healthy
individuals who might live a long life."
"It gives them a whole different perspective on what their potential
is," Evers said. "We do see people who change jobs, or go to school
who hadn't gone to school."