CONTACT: JOANNE FRITZ
5 Old Capitol
Iowa City IA 52242
(319) 335-0557; fax (319) 335-0558
New study of national universities calls UI 'rising star'
IOWA CITY, Iowa -- The University of Iowa is the 20th best public university
in the United States and is a "rising star" among its peers nationally,
according to a new study that uses objective data to rank American research
The study, conducted by researchers at Vanderbilt University and the University
of Maryland, measured the research productivity on a per capita basis of 203
universities as part of a larger look at American research institutions over
the past 45 years.
Using numerical indexes, researchers compared money received from federal
grants, the number of articles published across scholarly fields, articles
in top-rated scientific journals, articles in top-rated social science journals
and fellowships in the arts and humanities.
In the combined index for nationally ranked and rising public research universities,
the UI ranks 20th, tied with the State University of New York at Albany.
When only "rising" universities are considered, the UI ranks 10th
among the top 21. A "rising" university is defined as an institution
that did not appear in four, often-cited rankings of universities conducted
by national educational organizations during the past 30 years.
UI President Mary Sue Coleman said the study confirms the UI's standing as
a premier university whose faculty are leaders in creating and disseminating
"Iowans have long been proud of their commitment to education and the
legacy of excellence at the University," Coleman said. "While the
University has always been highly ranked based on national surveys, this is
the first study to confirm that our place among the leading universities is
based on scholarly achievements in several disciplines rather and not just
on reputation alone."
Results of the study are published in "The Rise of American Research
Universities: Elites and Challengers in the Postwar Era," by Hugh Davis
Graham and Nancy Diamond, and published by The Johns Hopkins University Press
Graham, Holland N. McTyeire Professor of American History at Vanderbilt,
said he and Diamond conceived the study as a way to objectively measure research
universities and their role as "creators of knowledge" since World
Other studies, many of them frequently cited by academics and administrators,
are based on the reputation of institutions, Graham said. A reputational survey
is open to bias through a "halo effect" that skews results toward
large universities and prestigious, private universities.
The new study controls for size by measuring factors on a per capita basis
and controls for the halo effect by comparing actual, published scholarship
"Our study measures real things," Graham said. "There is no
subjective component in our survey."
The study also separates public and private universities because of the different
political, educational and monetary issues facing the different types of institutions.
Graham said there are few surprises in the rankings of private universities.
But the new study found several rising stars, particularly among the California
and New York systems, that are overlooked by traditional surveys. Traditional
Big Ten powerhouses, Ohio State University and Pennsylvania State University
also dropped out of the top universities in the new study.
According to the study, the University of California at Berkeley is ranked
first among all nationally ranked public research universities.
Rounding out the top 20 are the University of California at Santa Barbara,
the State University of New York at Stony Brook, the University of California
at Los Angeles, the University of Michigan, the University of Wisconsin at
Madison, the University of Illinois, Indiana University, the University of
California at San Diego, the University of Colorado, the University of California
at Riverside and the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (tied for
11th), the University of Texas at Austin, the University of Washington, the
University of California at Santa Cruz and the University of Oregon (tied
for 15th), the University of California at Amherst, the University of Maryland
at College Park and the University of Massachusetts at Amherst (tied for 18th),
the University of Iowa and the State University of New York at Albany (tied